News Categories
Archives

Series 1-7 Face-Off Results: Everything Else (Episodes 9-13, Specials)

Across March and April Doctor Who TV pitted all the revival episodes so far against each other and asked you to vote on each. We’ve revealed your choices for both the Dream and Nightmare Run, now to wrap up it’s time to look at everything inbetween.

Catch-up on other articles:

Now join Mark McCullough as he examines the secomd half of episodes in the list.

NB: Having already looked at first and last place in each of the episode categories, there is no point in talking about them again. Instead I will focus on the five episodes which make up the middle of each set of results. Also, this time we have the percentage splits for each of the episodes so we can see how certain episodes fared. So without further ado:

Episode Nine

doctor-who-the-beastThe three two-parters conclude here and in an unexpected twist, The Empty Child usurps all three. Of course all four episodes are fantastic and equally deserving of doing well in the poll. What is actually quite interesting is when we look at the concluding parts of the story and compare them. The Family of Blood keeps a reasonably constant share of the vote yet manages to improve its position in relation to the others. The Forest of the Dead drops a place and a large share of its vote, whilst The Satan Pit does similarly to its predecessor. What this means is rather unclear, was the quality of the episodes different between each part? Or is it just a case of another good episode added to the mix? The remaining three episodes on the list are unsurprising, given its predecessor’s place on the list; Cold Blood was never going to do well. Hide does alright, but probably suffers from its ending and not quite delivering on the fear factor. As revealed in the Nightmare Run, Night Terrors aptly takes the bottom spot.

Episode Ten

vincent-and-the-doctor-cry-endThis was a really strong group of episodes, which all lost out on a spot in the Dream Run, due to the inclusion of the fan favourite, Blink in the poll. Vincent and the Doctor is a fantastic episode, exploring the mind of one of the greatest painters in history. It features some incredible scenes, but none quite as memorable as watching Vincent hearing the Curator speak about his work. Midnight is also a classic making use of the claustrophobic conditions and an unknown threat for tension. The episode has a strong focus on humanity and how far normal people will go under pressure. Then we have The Girl Who Waited, the narrative separates the Doctor from Amy placing them both in different time streams. This results in the heart-breaking choice of an older Amy or the younger version. It is a wonderfully poignant episode. The Doctor Dances fares worse than the opening part of its story, again the reason why is unclear. Perhaps the format of the poll even had a part to play. Journey to the Centre of the TARDIS is an episode which promised a lot and failed to live up to it. Coupled with that the dismal guest cast, and it is no surprise that it features near the bottom of this list, I actually believe it deserves last place more than Love & Monsters.

Episode Eleven

utopia-cast-tennantThis set of episodes was another very strong one. Turn Left proved to be a worthy winner with its unique take on the Doctor-lite format. Utopia also does extremely well in this section and deservedly so. The Master’s re-introduction came as a major shock and was extremely well delivered playing on the fob watch idea. Derek Jacobi gave a fantastic performance before regenerating setting up one of the biggest cliff-hangers in the history of the show. The God Complex offered a storyline which presented a strong focus on the Doctor-Companion relationship and was executed extremely well. Both The God Complex and Utopia are fan favourites and it certainly shows here. The Lodger takes the middle spot on the list which really isn’t a surprise, its light-hearted, friendly plot made for a welcome change and an brilliant episode. The Crimson Horror also fares reasonably well coming in fifth position. The paternoster gang are strong in this episode and complement the narrative well. Boom Town is another criminally underrated episode, but given the competition here I wasn’t expecting it to do well. Fear Her completes the list as the Nightmare Episode.

Episode Twelve

The Sound of Drums & Last of the TimelordsThe majority of the episodes here are the first part of a two-part finale. The two that are not, don’t fare particularly well at all, and I would guess that this is the reason why. Sandwiched between the two stand-alone episodes in sixth place is Army of Ghosts. This is rather surprising because it is quite a good episode, keeping the identity of the antagonist revealed until the end whilst building the threat of Torchwood throughout the episode. Back up to the glorious end of the results and The Pandorica Opens is our runaway winner. The Sound of Drums does very well in second place featuring some excellent scenes with John Simm as the Master. The idea of the Doctor and his companions as fugitives was also an intelligent one. The Stolen Earth features the disappearance of Earth from under the Doctor’s nose. His search for it leads him to the biggest Dalek plan for universal domination. The episode has a wonderful cliff-hanger too with the universe in danger and the Doctor regenerating. Bad Wolf intelligently integrates popular TV culture into the series whilst simultaneously showing the Doctor’s impact on situations is not always positive. Nightmare in Silver in my opinion is the worst episode on this list, the only thing which probably saves it is Matt Smith’s performance as the Doctor/ Mr Clever.

Episode Thirteen

big-bang-amelia-doctorFive of these episodes are the concluding part of an episode twelve. Of the two that aren’t, one tops the list whilst the other makes up the bottom. I’ll make it clear from the off, I don’t like either of them. Of the remainder, the two-parters, The Big Bang holds its position. Perhaps the smallest scale for a finale (set almost exclusively in a museum) turns out to be one of the most epic due to how character driven it is. From one extreme to the other, Journey’s End is next on the list. Arguably this was the largest finale putting all of reality at stake and reuniting all of the Doctor’s companions from that era of the show. The episode also featured characters from Torchwood and The Sarah-Jane Adventures. The Series One finale comes in next with a respectable portion of the vote. Christopher Eccleston’s departure was particularly tragic due to his short lived tenure in the lead role. The narrative of the finale allowed for the Doctor’s character development over the course of the series to be showcased. Doomsday is next and suffers from the Daleks vs Cybermen narrative which turns a lot of the fandom off it. In sixth place we have Last of the Time Lords which also suffers from its narrative, this time the Doctor’s divine resurrection. Two very minor issues, but with the quality of finales, enough to knock them down the list.

Russell T Davies Special

tennant-final-line-regen-want-to-go-end-of-timeThe Davies specials comprised a rather strange poll. As was expected both The Waters of Mars and The End of Time comprised a large share of the vote. This changes the dynamics of the rest of the episode meaning that their percentages are not reflective of their quality of the episode. I doubt anyone would dispute the inclusion of The Waters of Mars, however The End of Time received a much more mixed reception. Personally I love it, my favourite episode of the show. Brilliant moments between the Doctor and Wilf and a whole new approach to regeneration reflective of the Tenth Doctor’s characterisation made the episode for me. Of the Christmas specials there is little difference in their share of the vote. Each has their own merits. The Christmas Invasion removes the Doctor from the narrative leading to a high stakes tense story. The Runaway Bride introduces a future companion and shows the extent to which Rose’s departure affected the Doctor. Voyage of the Damned makes for wonderful family viewing and has a magical feel to it. The Next Doctor whilst the subject of much criticism also has some great moments especially when focusing on the character of Jackson Lake.

Steven Moffat Specials

time-old-matt-smith-shoutsFinally, to conclude the last section of our poll, we have Moffat’s specials. Having already discussed the runaway winner The Day of the Doctor and last place The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe, that leaves only the Christmas Specials to analyse. In second place unsurprisingly is The Time of the Doctor, Matt Smith’s swansong featured long-awaited answers delicately threaded into a narrative which took the Doctor to Trenzalore. A Christmas Carol featured a Doctor Who twist on an old Christmas classic as the Doctor tries to persuade a miserable old man to save the lives of those on a crashing spaceship. The inclusion of Abigail into the narrative makes for heart-breaking viewing. Finally in second last place we have The Snowmen, and introduction to (a) Clara and return for the Great Intelligence. Featuring killer Snowmen and the Paternoster gang, the episode balances fun with emotional impact perfectly to create a memorable Christmas special. I want to reiterate that all five of these episodes are fantastic and there is no shame for a bad position on this list.

Concluding Thoughts: By Series

So now we have the complete breakdown of each section of the poll, this allows for deeper analysis into the representation of writers and series within the poll. Granted the format means for an episode to get any votes at all, it must be considered the most exceptional of the set from which it belongs. So how does each series stack up:

Series Number

Average Percentage

Series Four

17.82%

Series Five

16.89%

Series Six

13.80%

Series Seven

13.34%

Series One

13.09%

Series Three

12.97%

Series Two

12.10%

What this shows up is rather interesting. To come up with these numbers I have taken the percentage vote for each of the episodes (excluding specials, as the RTD 2009 specials series would interfere) in each series, added them together and divided by thirteen to find an average. This number gives us an appreciation of the quality of a series as a whole whereas the Dream and Nightmare Runs gave us an indication as to which of the 7 series were more hit and miss. As you can see from the table, Donna’s stint in the TARDIS received the highest average vote suggesting it was the most consistently good series. Conversely Series Two takes the bottom spot (not surprisingly) meaning it is the least consistently good series.

RTD era vs Moffat era

moffat-rtdWith the numbers above you can now go into the breakdowns of specific eras by averaging the series within each of them. Doing so, the Davies era of the show averages as 14.00% whereas the Moffat Era comes out as 14.67%. I am aware that the debate of RTD vs Moffat is a popular one among fans, so these results are useful in that they show the difference in era over which we argue is only 0.67%. By taking this data and preforming statistical analysis of the two eras of the show we determine that the difference between the two is statistically insignificant, this is rather interesting. If don’t believe me, you can try yourself. I performed an unpaired t-test getting a result that p=0.7194 (I’m aware of my small sample size, but I would have got the same result using each episode individually.) The usually accepted value for statistical significance is p= <0.05. So there you have it, from a statistical point of view both eras of the show are so close that they are not worth arguing about which is better.

All Writers

With the series out of the way, now let’s analyse the results per writer using a similar method:

Writer

Average Percentage

Number of Episodes

Russell T Davies

10.41%

31

Steven Moffat

24.70%

25

Mark Gatiss

5.78%

6

Toby Whithouse

19.80%

4

Paul Cornell

18.81%

3

Tom MacRae

9.08%

3

Helen Raynor

4.28%

4

Neil Gaiman

20.65%

2

Phil Ford

44.16%

1

Robert Shearman

52.09%

1

Chris Chibnall

3.79%

3

What these numbers mean is not a huge amount in reality. Basically it signifies the percentage chance of a writer delivering a script capable of making its way into a dream run of the show. It’s not an indication of the ability of a writer, especially for Davies and Moffat who have contributed a large number of scripts each which actually ended up competing with each other. As a consequence the percentage for both writers was lowered slightly. Also Moffat has written in more episode slots giving him more opportunities to win and to boost his percentages. Notable here too are the one-hit-wonders who have written just the once for the show, but their episodes are really well received. To cover all the writers for the show would be unnecessary and overkill, so I’ve included the ones I have based on those I thought would be interesting. It does give some sort of indication as to who should come back in future.

That concludes the full analysis of the results of the Face-Off poll. Moffat managed a hugely impressive performance taking the majority of the Dream Run. Can he deliver again when it comes to Series Eight? Let’s hope so.

COMMENT GUIDELINES

Please be civil and keep article comments relevant and on topic. Flag and report any offensive/trolling behavior, or contact us with details.
Please do not post SPOILERS including anything from leaked episodes! Your account could be banned. For complete details on our comment policy please read.
263 comments
The Finn
The Finn

Aww, no love for VATD...

minifigureman11
minifigureman11

my personal favourite series:


1. Series 7


2. Series 5


3. Series 4


4. Series 2


5. Series 6


6. Series 3


7. Series 1


(Also I've just joined DoctorWhoTV. Hello!)


DW_girl
DW_girl

All the results I expected to be honest. I would've liked The Last of the Timelords to be higher though, as well as The Runaway Bride and Fear Her in their respective polls. The ones that cane out first and which I also picked for my dream run are: Turn Left, The Pandorica Opens, The Waters of Mars and The Day of the Doctor. The other episodes I picked which didn't make the dream run are: Forest of the Dead (a respectable 3rd), Midnight (3rd- should have at least been 2nd, although I love Vincent and the Doctor too), and The Big Bang (2nd place fortunately).

My ratings of the series in order of preference:

Series 4 10/10

Series 5 9.5/10

Series 3 9/10

Series 2 9/10

Series 7 8.5/10

Series 1 8.5/10

Series 6 7/10

I think series 6 has been over-rated in this poll, and series 2 under-rated. I thought series 2 was a lot more consistent than series 6!

The Living Angel / is Regenerating
The Living Angel / is Regenerating

P.s, enough of the endless polls for a while now please. We have had six months solid of polls, which one is better? Etc. I for one have had enough of polls for a while.

Planet of the Deaf
Planet of the Deaf

One thing I find slightly irritating is the number of comments below that claim that Name of the Doctor only won because it was more recent, rather than because of its own qualities



a) On that basis, shouldn't the rest of S7b have won seeing that this was the most recent series.


b) Dalek won 52% of the vote, so nobody had difficulty remembering that S1 episode!

master no six
master no six

My series ranking is like this:


1. Series 4

2. Series 1

3. Series 2

4. Series 3

5. Series 5

6. Series 6

7. Series 7

dazfd96
dazfd96

Series 2 is bright and wonderful and brilliant. Never knew, but from reading the comments a few others are saying they dislike series 2 the most too. Series 6, possibly 3 too were worse. 

The Moment
The Moment

Good overview however I do think Doomsday should have got at least 3rd!

JamesStroud
JamesStroud

Before I start scrolling and see complaints about things being in the "wrong" places, I would like to point out that, as the article says, THIS POLL WAS FLAWED in that you only voted for the best episode, and not rated episodes. It would be better to rate each episode out of 10, like was done for Matt Smith's era when he left, and then take a comparison if you want to compare episodes

bringmeknitting
bringmeknitting

I think Series 1 suffers from being the oldest. It's the only way I can explain the poor performances of Father's Day, The Doctor Dances and The Parting of the Ways... Personally I feel The Name of the Doctor has only won through being freshest in the memory and having three great moments, the rest of it isn't that spectacular with hindsight. I'm staggered to see the lack of support for The Doctor Dances - it's the gold standard for the second half of a two-parter as far I'm concerned, emotional, scary, very funny (the Doctor-Jack banter is a delight throughout) and that brilliant, punch-the-air double ending - the first and best use of 'everybody lives'.



NewWho2012
NewWho2012

Nice to see Series 4 take the top spot in regards to story strength and success. I always liked Series 4, especially in the Moffat era, the time when all fans were watching.

bringmeknitting
bringmeknitting

Journey's End higher than The Parting of the Ways? You're having a giraffe :(

dedpubserv
dedpubserv

So if you do this again, it might be fun to have people vote for the best and worst episode in each series. Also, you might want to omit "Day of the Doctor" from the voting, since that will likely triumph over any competition. 

awkward912
awkward912

Apparently we casually note Hide's phenomenal ending as being a disappointment without any further detail nowadays...

Ollie Walton Harrod
Ollie Walton Harrod

@DW_girl  I agree definitely. Series 2's actually my favourite. And it's all new to me that other people don't like it.

Ollie Walton Harrod
Ollie Walton Harrod

@dazfd96  I agree. I only just realised how much hate there is for series 2, mostly because there is a love story there.

Planet of the Deaf
Planet of the Deaf

@JamesStroud  Having to chose between episodes made this a much more challenging exercise than giving a whole load of great episodes 9s and 10s!

DWTV
DWTV moderator

Planning to do that next year, obviously with Series 8 added to the mix.

Rose_Tyler_I
Rose_Tyler_I

My series ranking:

1) Series 1

2) Series 4

3) Series 6

4) Series 2

5) Moffat Specials

6) RTD Specials

5) Series 3

6) Series 5

7) Series 7

TheElusiveWhovian
TheElusiveWhovian

My list

1. Series 5

2. Series 3

3. Series 7

4. Series 1

5. Series 6

6. Series 4

7. Series 2

MeglosProductions
MeglosProductions

@Baker Street… is the Moment!

1. Series 1

2. Series 4

3. Series 3

4. Series 5

5. Series 7 part 1

6. The specials

7. Series 2

8. Series 6

9. Series 7 part 2

The only series I dislike are the bottom three. The rest are pretty good.

DrunkenDalek
DrunkenDalek

But if people like it they like it, you can't just omit a politician from an election because they will win

SirTrey
SirTrey

@awkward912 I'll lead off by saying I love the discussion and fandom here...I'm pretty sure I was just agreeing with something you said a couple articles ago haha


But ehhhhh...yeah Hide floundered in the ending, 100%.  For me, the episode is pretty solid otherwise: the main relationship between the two supporting characters seems real and heartfelt, the Doctor and Clara both have good things to do, and it's a genuinely scary episode.  Or at least, it's a genuinely scary episode until Cross totally undermines that by turning the angry, frightening monster into a cutesy "it just misses its true love" ending.  

It undercuts a fantastic tone by refusing to stay dark and renders all of that fear as a simple misunderstanding.  The "misunderstood monster" was done better in 'Vincent and the Doctor' and the romance was done better in, well, the rest of 'Hide', but with the other two characters.  There was simply no need IMO to shove the monster in there and ruin a perfectly frightening episode.

Ollie Walton Harrod
Ollie Walton Harrod

@RobertLythgoe @bringmeknitting  I prefer Series 2. But Series 1 definitely comes second.

And I didn't like 'The Name of the Doctor' at all.

The Great Intelligence sacrificed himself to kill the Doctor by entering his timestream. Clara does the same to save him, thus killing her too. But somehow the Doctor manages to go in and bring her out. How did they get out exactly, if it wasn't possible without dying? The episode ended in the timestream, as a cliffhanger/lead in to the 50th Anniversary, but it was never explained how they got out. Also, after making a big deal about the Doctor's name, in that episode, the 50th, and the Christmas Special (as well as in the previous series), the answer was that it doesn't really matter.






Ollie Walton Harrod
Ollie Walton Harrod

My list:

Series 2

Series 1

Series 3

Series 4

RTD Specials

Series 5

Series 6

Series 7

Moffat Specials

Pertbaker34
Pertbaker34

I don't feel that it was great all around, but I actually think the ending is what redeems it. It's an extremely surprising, smart, and very Doctor Who ending that really deserves praise and not ridicule.

DWTV
DWTV moderator

Well there's not going to be another daily series for a bit, but there will be some one offs not far away.


DW_girl
DW_girl

What's so wrong with Rose's outfit?

Ollie Walton Harrod
Ollie Walton Harrod

@RobertLythgoe @Manyetha the Time Lord @Baker Street… is the Moment!

It was the worst by far. The only one I liked was 'Cold War' (other than that terrible CGI of the Ice Warrior's head (under helmet).

The Bells of Saint John - mediocre

The Rings of Akhaten - Really bad (kind of nice story with leaf memories, but a bit silly)

Cold War - Only when writing this just now thought, it kind of reminds me of Dalek. It's got that good, creepy feel that Doctor Who once had.

Hide - meh

Journey to the Centre of the Tardis - boring

The Crimson Horror - So stupid, (a breast feeding red alien) and possibly one of the worst episodes of Doctor Who I've ever seen.

Nightmare in Silver - Cybermen are awesome. Though apparantely now they can just upgrade against anything (except of course an exploding planet). They are way too overpowered now. Also, I thought they used to be allergic to gold dust, because it got into their breathing apparatus. Not anything coloured gold touching them.

The Name of the Doctor - The Great Intelligence sacrificed himself to kill the Doctor by entering his timestream. Clara does the same to save him, thus killing her too. But somehow the Doctor manages to go in and bring her out. How did they get out exactly, if it wasn't possible without dying? The episode ended in the timestream, as a cliffhanger/lead in to the 50th Anniversary, but it was never explained how they got out. Also, after making a big deal about the Doctor's name, in that episode, the 50th, and the Christmas Special (as well as in the previous series), the answer was that it doesn't really matter. 


SirTrey
SirTrey

@awkward912 @SirTreyIt works elsewhere, I didn't feel like it worked there.  I mean, to look at another example, one of the most universally beloved New Who episodes is 'Blink'.  And why?  Because that episode is 100% committed to the Weeping Angels.  They are terrifying, they aren't really stopped by anything except each other and even after they are "defeated" that chilling final sequence implies that there's a lot more out there.


If the Angels had actually been trapped creatures of light let free at the end that episode would've sagged completely.  I have a very similar feeling towards Hide.

Planet of the Deaf
Planet of the Deaf

@awkward912 @SirTrey  I agree, the whole essence of Doctor Who is that there's a whole world of amazing creatures out there, and rather than going around blasting them, the Doctor  wants to talk to them and make peace with them